It’s the end of the year, and you know what you want to ask your donors.
You've identified the opportunity, figured out the amount, and hopefully spent the last few months building the relationship that will lead to a meaningful conversation.
But then you actually have to, well, make the ask. What do you say? How do you bring it up without making the conversation feel awkward? And what happens if the donor doesn't immediately say yes?
I hear these questions from fundraisers all the time. Even experienced major gift officers can still get a little nervous when it's time to ask for a significant gift, especially when the calendar is closing in and there's pressure to meet a year-end goal.
Here's a reminder: A good ask is a conversation. You're inviting a donor to do something meaningful with you, and that conversation should give them the freedom to decide what's right for them.
That's the heart of Permission-Based Asking™. You create space for the donor to share what's important, connect their interests to an opportunity, and then ask whether they'd consider making a specific gift.
To help you put this into practice, I've put together a year-end ask script you can adapt for your own conversations. Think of it as a guide, not something you need to read word for word. The best conversations will always sound like you.
The Year-End Ask Conversation
1. Connect
Start by reconnecting with the donor as a person. Remember something they shared during your last conversation, whether it was a family update, a recent trip, or something else happening in their life. Give them room to talk before you move into the purpose of your call.
“Before we get started, I'd love to hear more about [the trip, family news, or whatever they shared with you in October]. How has that been?”
Listen carefully, repeating back each of their words in your head, and stay with this until they've finished.
2. Align
Once you've reconnected, remind the donor why you planned the conversation and make sure the timing still works. You want them to understand what you'll be discussing, while also giving them the opportunity to guide the conversation.
“Thank you for sharing that. As we discussed, I wanted to talk with you about an opportunity to have a great impact on [their area of interest]. Is that your understanding, and does [end time] still work for you today?”
“I also want you to know how much your partnership means to us and to the [people, animals, environment] we serve. Today, I'll be asking a few questions to make sure I'm aligned with what you want to accomplish through [organization]. Is that OK with you?”
3. Be curious
Now it's time to learn more about what the donor cares about. You may have a good understanding of their interests already, but people change, priorities develop, and new experiences can shape how they think about giving. Give them a chance to tell you what's on their mind.
“When we talked in October, you told me how much [specific concern, in their words] matters to you. What are your thoughts on that now? Has it changed or developed in any way?”
Pause, then follow what they say.
“How did you first develop that interest?”
4. Ask permission
Before you introduce an opportunity, ask whether the donor would be open to hearing about it. This is a small but important moment in the conversation because it gives the donor control over what happens next.
“You said earlier that the main reason you care about [X] is [their reason]. Would you be open to me sharing something I think you would care about?”
If they say no, you've learned something valuable. Thank them and ask what would be most helpful instead.
5. Present the opportunity
Now you can share the offer you've prepared. Keep it focused on the donor's interests, and use a real story from this quarter to help them understand the need and the difference their gift could make. A good offer connects a compelling need with a believable solution and a clear opportunity for the donor to take part.
“[Short description of the need, the solution, and the outcome, using one real story from this quarter.]”
Then invite their response:
“What stood out to you? What questions do you have?”
Give them time to think through what you've shared. Their questions can tell you a lot about what matters to them and what they need to know before making a decision.
6. Make the ask
The often-dreaded moment! But it doesn’t need to be. When you've had a chance to discuss the opportunity, make a clear, specific request. Name the amount, connect it to the project, and give the donor room to respond.
“Would you consider a gift of $[specific amount] for [project] before the end of the year?”
Stop talking. Let the silence sit, and let them respond first.
I know that silence can feel uncomfortable. You might be tempted to fill it by explaining the amount again, offering a lower number, or giving the donor another reason to say yes. Resist that urge! You've made your request, and now it's their turn to think and respond.
What to Say When the Donor Responds
Of course, the conversation doesn't end with the ask. Your donor may say yes, need more time, or decide the opportunity isn't right for them. Each response gives you a chance to respect their decision and determine what should happen next.
If they say yes
First, celebrate! Let the donor know how much their commitment means and connect their generosity to the outcome they're helping make possible.
“Thank you so much. I want you to know that [specific outcome] will happen because of your gift. [Tell the story of what will change.] I hope you can feel the joy and hope coming your way.”
Then make sure you understand the details of their commitment so you can follow through.
“So I have this right, you're planning on $[amount] for [purpose] by [date], and you'd like to give by [check, stock, DAF, or IRA]. I'll send you those details by [day].”
Be specific about the next steps, especially if the donor is giving through a donor-advised fund, stock, or an IRA. You want to make the process as easy as possible for them.
If they say maybe
A maybe can mean many things. Rather than guessing, get curious and invite them to tell you what's holding them back.
“Of course. What questions are still unanswered for you? What concerns do you have? What do you still need to be able to decide?”
Once you've talked through their questions, agree on a time to reconnect.
“When would be a good time for me to follow up?”
Then honor that timing. Your job is to help them make an informed decision while keeping the relationship comfortable and respectful.
If they say no
A no can be difficult to hear, especially when you've put a lot of thought into the opportunity. But remember, the donor has the freedom to decide how and when they give. Your response should reinforce that freedom and protect the relationship you've worked hard to build.
“I completely understand, and I honor your decision. It's really important to me that you feel total freedom in your relationship with us. Would you tell me a little more about your decision? I'd love to understand what matters most to you right now.”
If they're comfortable sharing, listen without trying to change their mind. You may learn something important about their priorities or circumstances. Then, if it feels appropriate, leave the door open for another conversation.
“Are you open to talking in the future about other giving opportunities? What timing would work best?”
Thank them for their honesty and keep the connection going in a way that reflects their interests.
After the Conversation
Once you've finished the call or meeting, take a few minutes to make sure nothing gets lost. A thoughtful conversation deserves thoughtful follow-through, and your next steps should be clear to both you and the donor.
If the donor said yes, make sure the gift details are clear and that any promised information gets to them promptly. If they said maybe, document their questions and the date you agreed to reconnect. And if they said no, record what you learned so your future communication reflects their preferences.
A Better Year-End Ask Starts with the Relationship
I know year-end can bring a lot of pressure. It's easy to get caught up in the amount you're asking for and forget that there's a person on the other end of the conversation.
So take a breath. Go into each conversation prepared, but stay curious enough to let the donor lead you somewhere you didn't expect. When you give them the freedom to share what's important and connect their passion to a meaningful opportunity, the ask becomes a natural next step in the relationship.
If you'd like to keep building your skills in Permission-Based Asking™, download our free white paper, How to Use Permission-Based Asking with Donors. It walks through the framework in more detail and gives you practical guidance for bringing it into your donor conversations.
And remember, your job isn't finished when you make the request. Whether the donor says yes, maybe, or no, you have an opportunity to strengthen their trust in you and your organization.
That's what relationship-centered fundraising is all about.